Preheat oven to 220°C/200°fan/Gas 7 and butter a large baking sheet
Mix dry ingredients in a large bowl. Add treacle or sugar, buttermilk and stout, mix with a knife, then use your hand to form a sticky dough
Tip dough out and knead a little until smooth. Cut in half then form each piece into a round. Put on baking sheet, dust with a little wholemeal flour. Cut a cross in the tops and bake for 35-40 minutes until they sound hollow when tapped on the base
Cool, then slice and serve with butter and honey or with smoked fish and a piquant salad, or with soup